Books have always been a rich source of inspiration for TV shows. From epic fantasy worlds to intimate love stories, books are full of imaginative and engaging stories.
But how faithful are these adaptations to the original story? Is it better to watch the show or read the book? And more importantly, why should we still trust in the magic of reading books?
Let’s explore this topic.
Books vs. TV Shows or Movies: The Age-Old Debate
Ever read a book and then watched its adaptation? If so, you’ve likely found yourself comparing the two. The debate over whether books or their screen versions are better has been around for years, and it’s something many people feel strongly about.
- The Power of Books
Books give us the chance to dive deep into the story. We get to imagine the characters, their thoughts, backstories, places, and even their emotions. When reading, we can spend hours in the world the author has created. Every small detail is laid out, and we have time to connect with the story on a personal level.
- The Appeal of TV Shows or Movies
Movies or shows, on the other hand, have a set runtime. They show us the story in just a couple of hours. They bring characters to life on screen, giving us a visual experience. For people who don’t have time to read a whole book, these adaptations are a quicker way to enjoy a good story.
- What’s Different?
When a book is turned into a TV show or movie, there are often changes. One significant difference is the level of detail. Since films and shows have limited time, they frequently cut out scenes or alter details to fit the format. This can be disappointing for fans, as their favorite parts might be left out or modified.
Screen adaptations are usually faster-paced, focusing on key moments, while books allow for slower development and more intricate storytelling. However, adaptations can sometimes make a story better by speeding up the pace or focusing on the most exciting and emotional parts.
Do TV Shows or Movies Stay True to the Books?
What does it mean for a TV show to stay true to the book? Staying faithful doesn’t always mean following every single plot point. It’s about keeping the essence of the original story– its characters, themes, and tone. Some adaptations stay very close to the source material, while others take more creative liberties.
Some TV shows work hard to stay as close as possible to the original story. Fans of the book can often appreciate the small details that make it into the show. For example, Outlander is a TV adaptation that remains faithful to Diana Gabaldon’s books. The characters, plot twists, and historical details are all there, with only minor changes for TV.
Another great example is the BBC adaptation of Pride and Prejudice. It followed Jane Austen’s novel closely, and fans appreciated seeing their favorite characters and dialogues come to life on screen almost exactly as they were written.
However, not all TV shows stick closely to the book. Some take big liberties with the plot, characters, or even the ending. The Witcher, based on the books by Andrzej Sapkowski, made many changes, especially in its second season. While some fans enjoyed the new direction, others felt that the show lost touch with what made the books special. Likewise, Game of Thrones is another one. The earlier seasons stayed true to the books, but later seasons started to drift. By the end of the series, the TV show had gone far beyond where the books had stopped. It leads to a completely different conclusion.
Are Books Better than Movie Adaptations?
Absolutely! Books are the best. They have many advantages that make them better than movie adaptations.
Books Deliver Details TV Can’t
Books offer a level of detail that TV shows simply can’t match. When you read a book, you get to immerse yourself in the world the author created. You can experience the setting, the character’s inner thoughts, and the subplots that TV shows often have to cut for time.
In the Harry Potter books, for example, many small but important details didn’t make it into the films. Relationships are explored more deeply, secondary characters have bigger roles, and there are entire subplots that were left out. Reading the books gives you access to the full world of Hogwarts in a way the movies could never offer.
The Emotional Connection Is Stronger in Books
One of the biggest reasons books are irreplaceable is the power of imagination they give the reader. When you read, your mind creates the characters, the settings, and even the emotions the characters feel. Not two people imagine a book the same way. You experience the story at your own pace, and this creates a stronger emotional connection.
In contrast, TV shows present a single, fixed interpretation. While this can be enjoyable, it limits the personal connection and creativity that comes with reading. A TV adaptation might offer a glimpse into a world, but a book lets you live in that world, imagining every detail in your own way.
True Fans Always Return to the Book
Even after watching a TV adaptation, true fans often return to the book for the full experience. The original text offers more depth, additional scenes, and details that the show might have missed. For fans who want to know everything about a story, the book is the ultimate source.
For instance, after watching The Handmaid’s Tale, many viewers decided to read Margaret Atwood’s novel. They found that the book offered more insight into the world of Gilead and the character’s thoughts.
Books Last a Lifetime, TV Shows Come and Go
While TV shows may entertain us for a while, books leave a lasting impression. A well-written book can be revisited time and time. It offers new insights with each read. It stays with you long after the last page is turned.
Think of classic novels like The Great Gatsby or Moby Dick. These books have been adapted into films and shows, but their true value remains in the written word. They continue to be read and loved by new generations that TV can’t replace.
Should You Read the Book Before Watching the TV Show?
Definitely! You should read the book before watching the TV show. It lets you experience the full story before any changes are made. You’ll understand the characters better and have the original vision in mind when you watch the show.
Plus, reading the book first means you can avoid spoilers! You’ll be able to watch the show without worrying about missing out on any big plot twists. You’ll have the original vision in mind, making the viewing experience even richer.
But, one great thing about watching TV adaptations is that they often introduce viewers to books they might not have considered before. Many people discover new authors and stories through TV shows, which can lead them to explore the original books and even other works by the same author.
For example, when Big Little Lies was adapted into a TV show, many viewers were inspired to read Liane Moriarty’s novel. It can open the door to a whole new world of reading.
Wrap-Up
While TV adaptations can be fun and engaging, books will always be the ultimate source of the original narrative. Whether a show stays true to the book or not, the full depth of the story will always be found within its pages.
So next time you hear about a TV adaptation, pick up the book first. You’ll gain a deeper understanding of the plot, experience the richness of the characters, and discover the magic that only books can offer—something that TV cannot fully capture.
Trust in books, and let them be your guide to great storytelling.
2 thoughts on “Books Adapted into TV Shows: Do They Stay True to the Story?”